Alteration type
10 valuesReaders (Gemini 3.8 Flash, GPT-6 Luna)Jev checkAdjudicatorGroup labelsTesting routes
Field
biomarker_alteration_type on every row. Jev agrees with the published value on 100% of 647 rows. “Readers agree” compares the two readers before adjudication. Select a value for its rows, or a Jev answer for the rows where it differs.2. No biomarker in the text (classic chemotherapy, anti-angiogenesis without biomarker gating) → biomarker_name="none", alteration_type="none", biomarker_detail="n/a", diagnostic_criterion="n/a", scoring_system="n/a", test_method=[] (empty list — no diagnostic test applies). Flag "no-biomarker" and "non-targeted-therapy".
2a. A hereditary tumour syndrome named as the population (von Hippel-Lindau disease, neurofibromatosis type 1, tuberous sclerosis complex) is a clinical diagnosis, not a biomarker: biomarker_name="none", alteration_type="none", scoring_system="n/a", test_method=[]. Put the syndrome into tumor_type (e.g. "VHL disease-associated renal cell carcinoma") and patient_eligibility, and flag "no-biomarker" but NOT "non-targeted-therapy". Record a germline biomarker only when the text names the alteration itself (e.g. "germline BRCA1/2 mutations").
3. Primary negative biomarker (e.g. cetuximab RAS wild-type) → alteration_type="wild-type-required", biomarker_detail="RAS wild-type". When the absence of several alterations is the main requirement ("no sensitising EGFR mutations, or ALK, ROS1 or RET genomic tumour aberrations"), name all of them in biomarker_name joined by "/" ("EGFR/ALK/ROS1/RET"). Secondary negative (e.g. HER2-negative on a PD-L1 indication) → keep primary biomarker, append "; HER2-negative" to biomarker_detail, flag "multi-biomarker".5b. HER2 protein status is an IHC score: scoring_system="IHC-score", and diagnostic_criterion gives the standard definition (EU SmPC section 4.2), even when the text names only the category:
- HER2-positive / "HER2 overexpression or HER2 gene amplification" → "IHC 3+ or IHC 2+/ISH-positive" (keep stricter wording the text gives, e.g. "IHC 3+").
- HER2-low → "IHC 1+ or IHC 2+/ISH-negative".
- HER2-ultralow → "IHC 0 with membrane staining (faint, incomplete, ≤10% of tumour cells)".
"HER2-low or HER2-ultralow" stays one row with both definitions. HER2 (ERBB2) mutation → alteration_type="mutation", scoring_system="n/a". A secondary "HER2-negative" does not change scoring_system.6. "PD L1" / "PD-L1" are the same — use "PD-L1". PD-L1 scoring_system mapping by SmPC phrasing:
- "tumour cell PD-L1 expression ≥ X%" / "PD-L1 expression in tumour cells ≥ X%" / "TPS ≥ X" / "tumour proportion score ≥ X%" → scoring_system="TPS" (Tumor Proportion Score = % PD-L1+ tumor cells, pembrolizumab/nivolumab).
- "combined positive score ≥ X" / "CPS ≥ X" → scoring_system="CPS".
- "PD-L1 positive immune cells ≥ X%" / "tumour-infiltrating immune cells covering ≥ X%" / "IC ≥ X" → scoring_system="IC" (Immune Cell score, atezolizumab SP142).
- "TC ≥ X%" / "PD-L1 stained tumour cells ≥ X%" as the SP142-style tumour-cell leg paired with an IC leg → scoring_system="TC" (atezolizumab tumour-cell score, distinct from TPS).
- "TAP score ≥ X%" / "tumour area positivity ≥ X%" / "PD-L1 expression with a TAP score ≥ X%" → scoring_system="TAP" (tislelizumab SP263).
- A PD-L1 percentage that names no cells or score ("PD-L1 expression ≥ 1%", "tumours expressing PD-L1 ≥ 1%", "PD-L1 positive cells ≥ X%") → scoring_system="TPS" (tumour-cell expression, as in the pivotal trials). Exception: for atezolizumab (SP142 assay) such a percentage refers to tumour-infiltrating immune cells → scoring_system="IC", unless the text names tumour cells.
- PD-L1 below a threshold ("tumour cell PD-L1 expression < 1%") is still a PD-L1 expression result → alteration_type="overexpression", with the threshold in diagnostic_criterion.7. Gene symbols uppercase (BRAF, EGFR, ERBB2). Use "PD-L1" (protein) not CD274. An HLA type is a germline genotype, never a mutation: "HLA-A*02:01-positive" → biomarker_name="HLA-A*02:01", alteration_type="overexpression", biomarker_detail="HLA-A*02:01-positive", scoring_system="n/a", test_method=["molecular"]. Hormone receptors are proteins measured by IHC: "hormone receptor-positive" → biomarker_name="HR", "oestrogen receptor-positive" → "ER", progesterone receptor → "PR"; use "ESR1" only for ESR1 mutations.
17. MMR / MSI alteration_type disambiguation. The text can present MMR/MSI status in two framings, and both carry clinical meaning but the enum forces a single choice:
- Protein-loss framing ("deficient mismatch repair (dMMR)", "loss of MLH1/MSH2/MSH6/PMS2", "MMR protein loss by IHC") → biomarker_alteration_type="loss".
- MSI framing ("microsatellite instability-high (MSI-H)", "MSI by PCR/NGS" alone, no mention of MMR protein loss) → biomarker_alteration_type="MSI".
- When the SmPC uses BOTH framings together ("dMMR or MSI-H", "mismatch repair deficient or microsatellite instability high", "MMR deficient / MSI high") → prefer biomarker_alteration_type="loss". Rationale: the primary molecular defect is MMR protein deficiency; MSI-H is the downstream consequence. Pathology labs diagnose this most commonly by IHC for MMR protein loss, so "loss" better captures the diagnostic workflow implied by the indication.Type of the PRIMARY biomarker alteration that gates eligibility in THIS ROW.
| Value | Definition (as Jev sees it) | Rows | Jev agrees | Jev answered instead |
|---|---|---|---|---|
mutation | gene mutation (e.g. EGFR exon 19 deletion, BRAF V600E, KRAS G12C, BRCA mutation, FLT3 mutation) | 87 | 100% | – |
fusion | gene fusion / rearrangement (ALK, ROS1, NTRK, RET) | 61 | 100% | – |
amplification | gene amplification | 0 | – | – |
overexpression | protein expression or overexpression, also below a threshold (PD-L1 expression ≥ or < X%, HER2 positive/low/ultralow, CD20 positive, CLDN18.2) | 120 | 100% | – |
loss | protein loss, incl. deficient mismatch repair (dMMR), also when written 'dMMR or MSI-H' | 13 | 100% | – |
MSI | microsatellite instability (MSI-H) framing only, without MMR deficiency wording | 0 | – | – |
TMB | tumour mutational burden | 0 | – | – |
signature | genomic signature, e.g. HRD positive / genomic instability | 1 | 100% | – |
wild-type-required | biomarker must be ABSENT / wild-type (e.g. RAS wild-type) | 23 | 100% | – |
none | no biomarker gates this row, including hereditary syndromes diagnosed clinically (VHL disease, NF1) | 342 | 100% | – |